List, I just got done giving a talk to a 2nd year music theory class at UM about temperaments and tuning. During the mind-wandering phase of a tuning earlier this week (would that have been the whole time??), I was thinking about the talk and came up with an analogy that seemed to work well this morning. The analogy is this: Equal temperament is like Dairy Queen ice cream - it all tastes the same, and you can mix it with any flavor of topping (i.e. key or musical style) and it still tastes good. Unequal/historical temperaments are like going to Baskin Robins - there are a lot of flavors to try, but you have to be more careful which flavor (temperament) you use with which topping (key, musical style). However, the results can be mouth-watering. Anyway, you get the idea. No new breakthroughs on what it all means, just another way to approach the topic with "non-temperament heads". Jeff Stickney, RPT University of Montana jpstickney@montanadsl.net
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC