[CAUT] RE : Tuning Hammer tip sizes, was Re: huge pitch raise question

[Jim Busby]

Hi Debbie!

 

Great to see your post. I agree (15 #3) but you can't find the good Hale
tips easily anymore. Watanabe (sp?) tips are now my preference. They fit
nicely and deep w/o touching the coil. I keep a #2 and #1 around but my
tip has never been changed in 6 years now.

Good advice.

 

Regards,

Jim Busby BYU

 

________________________________

From: caut-bounces at ptg.org [mailto:caut-bounces at ptg.org] On Behalf Of
DCyr141833 at aol.com
Sent: Friday, January 12, 2007 8:13 AM
To: caut at ptg.org
Subject: Re: [CAUT] RE : Tuning Hammer tip sizes,was Re: huge pitch
raise question

 

My preference is as Marcel and David Skolnik wrote - I also use a 15
degree, extra short, #3, all from Schaff (Hale).  It works really well -
for me.  I've been trying to find info for our students here at NBSS
about choosing a tuning hammer tip.  It seems that the Hale tips are
very variable - ie, a #3 is not necessarily the same as the next #3 -
some #3's are larger, some are smaller, same with the #2's.  A large #2
may actually be larger than a small #3.  Or at least it seats like it is
larger.  Maybe more or less taper is the correct terminology.  My
experience with Schaff is that if you order a tip and are not satisfied
with the way it fits, you can exchange it - no problems - but it's a
hassle.  It seems that the Watanabe tips that Pianotek sells are much
more consistent from tip to tip and in size.  And they seem to fit most
heads - at least the Schaff ones.  It does fit the Renner hammers that
Keith Bowman makes, which I think are Schaff.  Keith has a nice article
on the Renner website on tuning hammers - his preference is a #2 tip, 5
degree.  I couldn't possibly tune with that - but again, to each his
own.  But he really doesn't get into how it's bored and tapered, etc.  I
would like to see material on that also.

My advise to the students here at the school is to keep looking for tip
until you find the one that fits right for you.  But it seems like
consistency in manufacture could be a little bit better.

Debbie Cyr

North Bennet St. School

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/caut.php/attachments/20070112/2bcd36aa/attachment.html