[CAUT] slipping key slip

Susan Kline skline at peak.org
Tue Aug 10 19:27:45 MDT 2010


At 05:35 PM 8/10/2010, you wrote:
>Susan,
>That’s what I was thinking, too.  The piano has 
>been nicely restored (for a change) and was 
>refinished about 10 years ago, so it looks 
>pretty nice, still.  The refinisher did not have 
>woodworking skills, however.  This does not look 
>like recent damage.  It is a result of PMS (post 
>moving syndrome as Isaac calls it) and just old 
>age.  This last move finally did it in.  I want 
>it to be functional as well as nice looking.
>
>I have the woodworking skills
I guess what I was 
>wondering was if anyone had invented a better mouse trap.
>jeannie

If that much is missing, Jeannie, I think what 
I'd do is chisel out a 1/4" slot (for a brass 
strip) up at the top, where the front of the big 
flathead screw in the keyblock will rest, make it 
several inches long on the inner side, and take 
it to the edge of the keyslip on the outer edge, 
countersink one screw hole on the short side, and 
two holes on the long side, then epoxy the whole 
thing in to fill up any missing wood deeper than 
the 1/4". That would leave you enough wood (and 
epoxy) remaining to hold the screws in place.

Then make a wood inlay for the lower part, where 
the screw will just slide past. It won't get a 
lot of strain, only contacting the screw head in 
the keyblock as the slip is being installed. If 
you use wood for the whole thing, then you're 
just depending on the glue to hold it in.

I had a similar situation (only MUCH worse) with 
the lyre of a 1901 Knabe concert grand. The lyre 
had two big fat dowels coming out the top, 
sliding into cylindrical holes in the keybed, and 
held in place by hinge pins (well, lyre pins, one 
would say) through little holes in the sides. And 
one of the holes had to be slanted, to miss the 
shift lever. Hence on that side (the right pedal 
side) only 1/4" of keybed wood was holding the 
whole thing in, even when it was brand new.

When I met the piano the first time, the lyre was 
hanging by the very tip of the right  lyre pin, 
held by 1/4" of (egged out) wood on the far side 
of the hole, plus a little help from the other 
pin, which was very loose but still more or less 
intact, since the pin hadn't had to slant. 
Somebody had obviously installed an inlay on the 
bad side, because the wood of the keybed had a 
large smooth section exactly 1/4" below the 
keybed surface. The inlay was completely gone.

I took a rubbing of the area missing the inlay. I 
found a scrap piece of 1/4" mild steel plate. I 
hacksawed and ground it to match the missing 
area, and drilled and countersunk three holes for 
substantial flat head wood screws into the 
keybed. Installing it was cute. It was slightly 
proud of the hole for the dowel, and I was filing 
and grinding it with a dremel, periodically 
trying to get the lyre back on. I was under the 
piano on my back trying to keep metal filings out 
of my eyes when the pastor walked in ...

Eventually I got it installed, but there was 
still the problem of the egged out lyre pin 
holes. I ended up sliding matt board between the 
top of the lyre and the underside of the keybed, 
and eventually the lyre was rock steady. It 
stayed that way for a number of years, until the 
piano, which had ended up belonging to the 
Newport Arts Center after the Community Concerts 
folded, got traded to Portland as partial payment 
for Newport's  new Steinway D. I wish I knew 
where that big old Knabe ended up -- it gave us 
some wonderful concerts -- an object lesson about 
what different artists can do when unexpectedly 
presented with a 19th century sound, but in a 
decent well-regulated piano. It must have lived 
on the West Coast for many years -- the board was 
still in very good shape. (The pianists didn't 
need to know it had a Langer action in it -- you 
couldn't tell from playing it.) Some of them made 
a real meal of it, with enthusiasm. A few 
obviously hated it, but they weren't the ones I 
enjoyed listening to anyway. Community Concert 
artists going to a small town on the Oregon coast 
probably expected a beat out Yamaha in a school 
gym, so it was fun giving them something better, 
but not your average Steinway D, for sure.

Susan Kline

>
>
>----------
>From: caut-bounces at ptg.org 
>[mailto:caut-bounces at ptg.org] On Behalf Of Susan Kline
>Sent: Tuesday, August 10, 2010 4:42 PM
>To: caut at ptg.org
>Subject: Re: [CAUT] slipping key slip
>
>I greatly favor the repair Ron showed us, over this.
>
>I don't think that making an inlay on both sides 
>would be too hard. One could also inlay 1/4" 
>brass instead of maple, held in by short 
>flathead screws, with the edges filed to bevels, 
>but I would use wood instead, unless the piano gets beat up a lot.
>
>Susan Kline
>
>
>
>Apparently, only one side of the wedge is necessary.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://ptg.org/pipermail/caut.php/attachments/20100810/1a336731/attachment-0001.htm>


More information about the CAUT mailing list

This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC