Jim D; With due regard to Don R. we have had fiction in the journal for years. Remember the article that ran which suggested you could/should cut old strings with a cold chisel placed on the plate bearing bar and tapping sharply, and that doing so without releasing tension eased the job ? And how about the humorous ad for 'molecular purified piano soundboard water', although that came from The Valley Tech and I'm not sure if that was fiction or just plain madness! A little fiction, addressed in a constructive manner, is certainly acceptable and I bet that it would receive a wider readership than most of the highly technical tuning articles. Wait!! I'm not saying that these articles are not beneficial but you have to admit that it takes some study of each one in order to derive benefit from it. If you are like me, I am still trying to figure out how to use an SAT, a little of these type articles goes a long way. The advantage of having a journal is that everyone has an opportunity to submit articles and if somone would rather submit an article written in a fiction style, so be it. The only judge as to whether or not an article should be published is the benefit the readership will derive from it and Steve has been doing a good job of deciding that. "dislexia" --spell checker broke Jim ? Besides forsing me to use mi spell cheker is unfare, her is in NC. We need to bear in mind that some of the persons on the list are writing to us in their second or third language and that they probably do a better job with english than we can do in their native language. Now Jim, be gentle with me I'm in crisis, I just discovered that 'diminished fifth' has a meaning besides being a half empty bottle of Southern Comfort. Jim Bryant (FL)
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC