Hi Bill, that was a nice email! I enjoyed that. And I also enjoyed the skillful opinions about Steinway qualities! I like piano hammers very much. I think that hammers are the "jewels' of the instrument. For about = the last 10 years I have had an urge to look sharper and sharper into = hammer matters. I have come to the conclusion that new hammers, when made by a well = known factory (like Renner, abel and Yamaha) hardly need no any = hardener at all, except in the highest octave. Furthermore, if a new hammer needs hardener in other sections, then = something is wrong with in the factory and an immediate discussion = should follow with the makers (if you like your business relation = with them). I am curious about the American Steinway hammers, I do = not know them. I only know the Renner and Abel products (aside from the Yamaha's and = the Steinway's). It may be very well possible that I am old fashioned, and I should = certainly take into consideration that America is another world with = different tastes (so I heard, is that true?) and I am very curious = what you all think about this. Do you (Americans) think of Europe as another world with another = taste for sound? What is in your opinion the general "sound = difference" between these two parts of the world? I also think that way too little attention is given to voicing at = piano tech schools (from what I know of European schools) .These = days, a technician (overhere) can actually only make real progress by = going to a factory. I went to a couple of them so I know, and it is = really too bad for the other technicians for they are hungry too but = have no possibillities because of their jobs, their boss or financial = matters. That is why a better education is very much necessary. And I have come to yet another conclusion : A beautiful tuning is very important, but, since our ears are quite = flexible as we all know, a "wonderful" touch and a masterly voicing = are even more important because a performing pianist feels = immediately happy and comfortable and this will add to his "balance". Besides, voicing is the most difficult of the three (regulation, = tuning, voicing) and I personally would love to spend more time with = voicing masters!! An imperfect tuning can be masked by a skilled = intoneur... I'd like your opinions about these wonderful matters! PS I like Yamaha hammers too, what about you? >It's easy to surmise that this is caused by the bellywork. Playing a >crescendo on repeated note will diagnose this very common problem. I = think >it's >fair to note that both factory and field technicians who use "Method B" >routinely are equally to blame, if they create the inverse = brightness/power >curve thereby. It seems to me that the place to apply hardener is where = the >hammers need it, not by following either Method A or B. > >There, I've stuck my neck out, and it's been fun. What do you think? > >Bill Schneider >schnei78@pilot.msu.edu > Friendly Greetings from: CONCERT PIANO SERVICE Andr=E9 Oorebeek Amsterdam, the Netherlands email address: oorebeek@euronet.nl =89 Where Music is no harm can be =89
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC