Tom, I concur you probably have a knuckle problem but suspect it has to do with loose knuckle leather moving with the jack during letoff. If you find it is loose when squeezing the knuckle between your thumb and finger, it will probably help to tighten the leather. Best bet is to detach leather at one end on the knuckle, and reglue the leather tightly with a small spring clamp. I modified a bunch of small 4" Pony Brand spring clamps for this purpose Here is the easy modification. These are Pony #3201 clams. Slide off the rubber tips and you'll see a flat portion at the end of the tip. With a pair of parallel grip pliers, bend the tips in to each other at an angle so they now touch in an angle that will allow you to put the clamp onto the knuckle leather wjhile pressing it in tightly to the core. You will find this tightening to be of value in many actions that have drag in the letoff. We routinely do this tightening on brand new knuckles also since they are usually loose right out of the box. Yes, even on the "good quality" ones if they are loose. It can make a dramatic improvement in mushy feely actions at letoff as well. ,Try it and let me know if you like it! Ed Hilbert, RPT
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC