Roger, Ralph, list; There being a place to discuss this "problem" better than Pianotech? I don't think so. It is the appropiate place IMHO. That being said I need to put in my two cents worth on the subject. I personally have absolutely no qualms in taking one of the "domestic production" pianos and rebuiding it for resale or for a customer. I have done so for the past five or six years and have had absolutely zero (0) problems. None of the traumatic happenings that Roger is afraid of and certainly nothing that does not happen to pianos made for the "American Market". I have units from the mountains of NC to the coast,on the beach, in FL spanning dry and wet climates. I am selective about the pianos I will rebuild and very pleased with the results. No piano, that leaves my shop, leaves with just two pedals. Either it has a working sostenuto or it has a bass sustain pedal. Very carefully.......let me say that the only major, if thats what it was, problem I have had in this period of time is once when I neglected to hand rub the underneath of the large portion of the top on a C3. Anyone that believes the Japanese will accept inferior workmanship or materials in their own "domestic" pianos is not dealing with the facts. The Japanese people are insistent on quality in their pianos more so than Americans tend to be. In spite of Mr. Hayashidas protestations to the contrary the material used in "Domestic" production may differ in drying (doubtful) but not in quality. The problems one sees in these "Japanese domestic" pianos are the same exact problems we see in our "domestic pianos", i.e., If you take a S&S or Baldwin and put in on the plains of Mantobia, without proper precautions, you will experience the exact same problems that you will with a "Jdp". I do agree with you, Roger, that there does seem to be an inordinate amount of "green" gunk on some of these instruments and, like you, have consigned the cause to be indutrial pollutants. As long as there are dealers willing to foist these, 'used', mostly out of production, pianos off on customers, as top of the line instruments, there will be a problem with them but the problem is one of dishonest dealers, dishonest and/or incompetent techs, and not inferior instruments.......... Just one more opinion. Jim Bryant (FL) "just because it is true does not mean that it is absolute" Faintly Dull
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC