I draw the line when someone sets themselves up as an authority by publishing a book or other media intended for the uninitiated. If one does this without legitimate qualifications as a recognized authority and with great care to teach reliable methods, they are open to scrutiny. My first experience with Stevens' book was when I discovered that he advocates _bending_ the pin when tuning to _save_ the pinblock from wear. Years ago, I got into a brief online debate over this with part-time tooner that was presenting himself in the forum/newsgroup as an authority. He cited Stevens' book as his authority. I was certain that he had misread or misinterpreted the book until I had checked it out and found otherwise. This illustrates what kind of damage and confusion can be caused by self-appointed experts that are out of touch with the field they are claiming to represent. For this reason I think we have the right and duty to be critical of these books and those who publish them. Mark Story, RPT Eastern Washington University mstory@ewu.edu -----Original Message----- From: Robert B Edwardsen <edwardsn@mail.rpa.net> To: pianotech@ptg.org <pianotech@ptg.org> Date: Saturday, October 25, 1997 4:16 AM Subject: Re: Do you know this Man ??????? >In a message dated 97-10-24 20:20:24 EDT, Les Smith wrote: > ><< Anyway, at the risk of offending any of "Dr." Stevens friends and col- > leagues who may be on this list, I'll simply point out that as Will Rogers > once said, sometimes P.H.D. stands for "piled higher and deeper". >> I pulled out my copy of "Piano Tuning Repair & Rebuilding" and found that Stevens PHD is from is from the Free Protestant University, St. Andrews College, Great Britain. I must admit his book was the first complete text I read on piano technology and although he did have some bad ideas (putting mirrors on old uprights, using a hot glue gun to install keytops) it was a good general introduction to the profession at that time. After all, whom among us does not have repair skeletons in out closets? Rob Edwardsen, RPT 21 Courtenay Circle Pittsford, NY 14534-2101 716-586-1360 edwardsn@rpa.net
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC