> In a message dated 98-03-06 17:46:20 EST, you write: > > << We DO NOT know that Thomas Jefferson indeed tuned pure fifths. >> However to research what this tuning might have been, I decided >> to start with pure fifths. >> > If you are interested, I can supply the information on how to tune this > sequence with 1/5, 3/11 or 1/6 syntonic comma 5ths which are far >more likely > to have been used...... look at the 1/5 >meantones and some of the supporting documentation of them in Jorgensen's >book, Tuning, While I don't agree totally with Jorgensen's premise that temprements in those days were difficult or impossible to tune because a lack of 20th century knowledge of beat phenomena, it surely would have been impossible for those who lacked training from a specialist. However, there is one temperament consisting of only just fifths that anyone then or now could approximate close enough with no training and only a few written instructions. In a nutshell:Tune six just fifths up from MC and five down. Play and enjoy. Don't worry about the thirds, that's "key color". When the wolf bothers you, you are ready for another lesson. I suppose for the total tyro a paragarph should be included about beats and beatless octaves and beatles fifths. Great thing interlibrary loans. Now all I gotta do is come up with the postage back. "Tuning" weighs six pounds!!. Richard Reading the Book Moody
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC