I don't think anybody's mentioned letting the customer decide -- in as non- loaded a way as I can I explain the virtues of splicing (stability, tonal match, lower cost) as well as those of replacement (cosmetic, maybe their piano is almost new anyway, etc.) and let them decide. I mention that they're only out 5-10 minutes for the splice, and that the string can be replaced later if they want. Some decide that the splice isn't going to show anyway, and some decide that it offends their sensibilities, but they choose. In practice room situations where it is up to me, splicing is first choice except for speaking length splices, which are temporary. There is a SLIGHT tonal difference in the overtone structure of a spliced treble wire, because of the difference made by the knot in the front duplex, or sometimes when the stagger pin bend gets drawn into the speaking length, but.... Bob Davis Stockton, CA
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC