Jerry Hunt wrote: > Obviously, on this piano, I can't do both. Granted, the sharps may be > worn slightly (I repainted them) but I wouldn't think they would be worn > that much. Which is preferable, sharps 1/2" above whites, or top of keys > (excluding keytops/sharp cover) level? > > Thanks, and I hope my scenario is clear. > -- > Jerry Hunt > Dallas, TX Hi Jerry, You have to go with what works. If you want the sharps 1/2 inch above the whites, the sharps would have to be 1/2 inch high. The important thing is that the sharp, regulated with the proper aftertouch, does not come too close to the adjacent white keys (at least 1/16th above). The exciting thing about this vocation is the variables. The manufacture's specifications are a starting point and from there you proceed to make it work. It is not important that the top of the keys is level or that the sharps are exactly 1/2" high but it is important that the piano plays well. You have to use your best judgment about what is best for this piano based on the piano and the requirements and preferences of the owner. This is a lot to ask for and it is why we should never quit trying to learn. Norman Barrett Memphis, TN
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC