Hi Paul, I think I would use felt or wool cloth. This material is more compressible and rebounds better than leather. Felt tends to be quieter than leather when parts move against it. As for the four holes, stick something in them, like long screws. I would look at putting screws between the pedal to relieve the stress there. How was this held together in the first place? Newton
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC