> > Ron > > Point well taken. But that opens up a whole new subject. Perhaps Del, or one > of the factory reps, can chime in on this. At what point does a manufacturer > say, "this isn't done right, lets do it again." There's got to be some QC. If > > the engineering is done right, and the jigs make the parts the same way, how > come one piano has a great sound, and another, from the same line, same > factory, same people, is dead? What is the criteria in the factory for > replacing the board? > > Wim Well, no, it doesn't open up a whole new subject. The thread title was "killer octave" wasn't it? That was the subject of conversation, and you did say that manufacturers corrected these problems before they went out. It's dead center to what we are discussing. The killer octave is still primarily a soundboard problem, regardless of who tries to pass it off as a voicing problem that a dealer's field repair will correct, and that's my point. If manufacturing processes and QC of a given manufacturer had any concern for soundboard functionality built into the system (other than at the theoretical level), we wouldn't see characteristic killer octave problems in those manufacturers' instruments, would we? The majority of working piano technicians don't understand enough about soundboards to diagnose poorly functioning ones as anything but voicing deficiencies, if they notice them at all, so the vast majority of poorly functional to outright dead soundboards aren't accurately addressed. Whether through simple ignorance or intentional dishonesty, most of the sales and service industry will look ANYWHERE but at the soundboard for solutions. Seems to me the revered "soul" of the instrument ought to get passing consideration somewhere in the process, and be accurately reported to the dealer, manufacturers, and customer when it fails instead of throwing the standard dealer "fix" of denial and customer massage at it. I suppose if I was a dealer instead of the guy that was expected to make it go away cheaply, I'd see it a little differently - but that's one of the many reasons I'm not a dealer. Ron N
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC