[OT] Aural versus ETD tuning training

Ron Nossaman RNossaman@cox.net
Mon, 30 Dec 2002 13:09:56 -0600


>Was that Ron's point?  I didn't read it that way.
>
>David Love

My point was that the piano, while "common" and "familiar" to a lot of 
pianists, is quite complicated. Pianists aren't going to learn a lot about 
how the instrument works, or doesn't, by playing it. They might or might 
not like what they feel and hear, but they aren't normally going to be able 
to mechanically diagnose it either way.

The secondary point was that the pianist trying to get more technically 
specific information from the tech, will get different answers to the same 
question from different techs. This was not the primary point. It was to 
reinforce the observation that pianos are complex. Even members of the 
technical community disagree on what's what, so how are the pianists 
expected to know what their tech may very well not?

That's it.

Ron N


This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC