Ron, That's an interesting idea. I had thought of it too. I think it would certainly be a good place to start. It would give an indication of what the sound is like when individual notes are played and would certainly allow a side by side comparison of notes throughout the scale. The shortfall, in my view, is that I usually really judge a piano by sitting down and playing it rather than listening to individual notes. With a half and half piano it would be difficult to make an evaluation in this way. However, given that it's probably going to be nearly impossible to build two identical pianos, one with wapin and one without, then it's a better idea than anything else I can come up with at the moment. If I were the wapin people I would think this would be a great selling tool (assuming of course that the wapin unisons do in fact show better - maybe they've already tried this and thought better of showing it to the public). Phil F On Mon, 28 Jan 2002 22:53:28 Ron Nossaman wrote: >>I was wondering if everything else was exactly the same. When trying to >>determine >>if changes actually are improvements part of the problem is isolating the >>change >>you're interested in from all the other changes. > >This is why I and a few other folks out there have suggested that >Wapinizing every other unison throughout the scale of a demo piano would be >a very informative indication of what the difference really is. > > >Ron N >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC