hello Ed That is exactly what I have felt as "filtering" or "preferred velocity modes" I've wrote about - and say they seem to me to be work against the controllability of the action. There is a separate kinetic energy treatment in the key that makes me feel a key that is a little outside the whole system (a "separate key"). Comfortable, but less manageable, tending to drive your playing in some power level ass soon you are in the concerned acceleration zone. That is adding a new sensation between the pianist's hand and the piano hammer, certainly very useful to "beat daddy eight to the bar", not convinced by other possibilities offered ... Repetition seem to be better nowadays. My take is that the key is bending even out of a heavy stroke, if more mass is near the balance point it is also adding flexibility in the last portion of the key (toward the capstan), providing more reaction effort on the capstan - this have to be stated in more correct terms certainly. With the lead located farther toward the front the whole action is acting as a spring in my view of those things, You wrote : > And just for fun, If we accept that key bending is setting the limit on power an action is capable of, the leads in the center of the key will still be moving when the front of the key has hit the punching. (if the key is flexible enough to bend under a heavy stroke, then the portion of the key near the balance point will lag behind the outer extreme end,no?) . So, it may be that the key with the leads near the balance point will function as a mechanical capacitor, releasing energy after the end of the key, (and finger) has stopped moving. I've also noticed, that more mass is always perceived, no matter how it is distributed. I thought that most where agreeing that a good standard pattern was giving us what we where after enough. Best Regards and happy end of the year. Isaac OLEG > > > > Ed Foote RPT > www.uk-piano.org/edfoote/ > www.uk-piano.org/edfoote/well_tempered_piano.html > > _______________________________________________ > pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC