----- Original Message ----- From: Ron Koval <drwoodwind@hotmail.com> To: <pianotech@ptg.org> Sent: Thursday, March 20, 2003 9:17 AM Subject: HT tests > ric M looking for test offsets: > > Hi ric > > Here are the numbers for the test that is currently being run: > > C 5 > C# 1 > D 3 > D# 3 > E -2 > F 5 > F# 0 > G 5 > G# 2 > A 0 > A# 4 > B -1 > > These are then set over an ET curve to get to the desired temperament. > > I don't have a copy of big red, so I do not know what methods Jorgensen used > to get to these numbers. Maybe someone else can jump in as to the > methodology. I know that looking at Ellis' (p485) measurements, the numbers > don't seem to match. > Ron Koval For those interested in Ellis's original research, but considering the book is in copyright and in print, (Dover) I urge those interested to buy the book or at least check it out from a library. But for study purposes and perhaps after seeing these tables, someone might want to buy the Dover edition of "Sensation of Tone" containing the Ellis appendices. In that case I suppose it might be OK to share for through private request. (In the form of excel spreadsheets.) They allow you to enter cents offsets to compute beat rates. They will translate his table of "Piano Tuning--Fourths and Fifths into cents offsets. They will translate cent offsets into cents from C, where C is 0 C# is 100, D is 200 or which ever deviation it is. This shows the size of any interval with simple arithmetic. ---rm
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC