John writes: << I was indeed asking how to tune a well temperament for an aural tuner, though all that didn't seem to come out :) A few questions if you don't mind: >>What is 1/12 of a comma? Just a shade under 2 cents, real near an ET fifth. >>When doing step 3 in the P.B. '93 well temperament (and step 3 of Kirnberger) where tuning the Eb, Ab, etc. via just fifths I presume you are to cover over 2 octaves? << I assume Paul would have you extrapolated via the octave to keep the bearing plan with one. >>And when it says "Spread this around the keyboard" I presume that is tuning those notes in different octaves around the keyboard?<< That is the way I assumed it to mean. Paul can give you more details, (I expect him to be jumping in here for updates on his temperament, soon enough). >>I am particularly interested in the Young 1799 temperament, which seems to be highly regarded. Does anyone have a details that could help an aural tuner?<< Yes, The Young temperament was an ideal of perfect balance, however, on the piano, it may be that the 21 cent F#-A# is too much for some. I used to use this as an introduction to temperaments for the uninitiated, but found that too high a percentage of customers were put off by it. If you want to try it, I would suggest that you follow Thomas Young's abreviated version of instruction as published by Owen Jorgensen. "In practice, nearly the same effect (temperament), may be very simply produced, by tuning from C to F, Bb, Eb, Ab, Db, Gb, six perfect fouths; and again, from C, tune six equally imperfect fifths, (ie, C-G-D-A-E-B-F#) . This results in a Valotti that is transposed up a fifth, which leaves C as the most consonant key rather than Valotti's F. Notice that you end up with a Gb when tuning by perfect fourths from C, and that same note is an F# when you approach it from C by imperfect fifths. This will leave a rather active third between F# and A#, but that will be the widest third in the temperament. Now, if you would like to excercise control over how strong the temperament is, the following is a magical procedure from Jorgensen that allows the tuner to make decisions in regard to allotting the dissoannce. Tuning To Personal Taste (Jorgensen) All fourths are wide or Just, all fifths are narrow or Just 1. tune C to fork 2. tune C4-E4 according to taste (Just or wide) 3. tune E4 - E3 Just 4. tune G#3 between E3 & C4 so Ab-C is 1.25 times as fast as E-G# Tune the following intervals Just for Well temperament, (or very slightly tempered for Victorian if C-E is beating at least 4 bps). 5. G#3-C#4 6. C#4 - F#4 7. F#4 - F#3 8. Ab3 - Eb4 9. Eb4 - Bb3 10. tune D4 between Bb3 & F#4 so D -F# is1.25 times as fast as Bb-D 11. tune G3 from C4 & D4 so G-C beats 1.3 as fast as G-D 12. tune A3 from E3 & D4 so A-D beats 1.3 times as fast as E-A 13. tune B3 between F#3 and E4 so B-E beats 1.3 times as fast as F#-B Check G3-D4 is slower than A3-E4 G3-C4 is faster than A3-E4 A3-D4 is faster tahn G3-C4 14. tune F4 from Bb3 & C4 so C-F beats 1.5 times as fast as Bb-F Beat rates should increase in order from E3-B3 Bb3-F4 B3-F#4 B3-E4 E4-A4 If steps 5 - 9 are tuned in Just intonation, the C-E third controls the harmonic balance. If it is Just, a temperament like Kirnberger(Prinz) results. If C-E is tuned faster than 4 bps and less than7 bps, only F#-A# is 21.5 cents wide and the results are more "Victorian". Enjoy! Ed Foote RPT http://www.uk-piano.org/edfoote/index.html www.uk-piano.org/edfoote/well_tempered_piano.html
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC