Bernhard Stopper wrote: > I agree with Ron O. > > One should not confuse "Harmonicity" (what is not defined as a physical > parameter) with Inharmonicity. > Inharmonicity is definded as the offset of the harmonics by the effects of > the stiffness of the string and is therefore not dependent of the hammer. It > has nothing to do how "harmonic" impression that different hammers produce > by enforcing or damping different partials. > > Bernhard Stopper > > > Defined such there is of course no argument, and Ron O is correct as Bernhard points out... by definition. Yet there is measureable divergence from this apparently having to do with the condition of the moment of excitement. That, if true, cant be overlooked either.... tho perhaps a definitions of terms are in order for any such discussion. Cheers RicB
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC