Has anybody considered a split washer as a torsioning device on flanges. I think it may take up the "slack" during dry times, thus preventing loosening of flanges over time. Also since the Allen key wrench with a "ball" tip is very easy to insert in a blind situation could this make a good alternative for situations requiring tightening frequently. Bruce Browning-The Piano Tuner Phillip Ford <fordpiano@earthlink.net> said: > >I think the real difference between these two tools is the torque range they > >produce. The Power Grip is 0.3 to 3.5 in-lbs. Joe's Panasonic is 3.5 to 26 > >in-lbs. Obviously, a job that one of these tools works for, the other will > >not. Now the question is how much torque makes for a happy flange? > > Good question, for which I don't have a good answer. At the moment, all I > can say is that I tighten the screws until they feel tight enough to my > 'torque wrench', otherwise known as my hand. I did an archive search on > action screw torque but didn't come up with anything (did come upon some > other interesting things though - I find looking in the archives is like > looking in a dictionary, I get so interested in all the other stuff I see > that I forget what I went to look up). > > > >It would seem to me that 3.5 in-lbs would be way less than that needed for a > >flange screw. Yes? No? > > > >Terry Farrell > > I've never done any torque measurements with the Power Grip, so I can only > give you anecdotal evidence at this point. I agree that 3.5 in-lbs sounds > way too low for a flange screw, and based on my experience with the tool > I'm surprised at that figure for max torque. The torque settings on the > tool are 1 - 5. I normally use something like a setting of 3 to run action > screws in. That makes them as tight as I want them to be. I actually > prefer to do the final tightening by hand, so that I can feel how tight the > screw is. I use the tool for running of screws in and out to save my > wrist. With the torque limit on the max setting I've had no trouble > running screws into a new Steinway rail with only pilot holes. So, for my > uses, the tool has adequate torque. > > As far as the question of how tight action screws should be, I'll measure > the torque on screws that I think I've tightened adequately and report > back. That will give one data point (probably not very convincing). But > if a few other people do the same we might get a better picture. Also, > someone like Don Mannino can probably give us official factory figures for > this. > > Phil Ford > > > _______________________________________________ > pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives > --
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC