> I agree. I think that's the crux of this discussion. If the cap material > is strong enough (hard enough) then with a humidity increase it will push > the string up and the cap won't indent. Or the string will be pushed up the pin, and the cap will indent anyway. >When the humidity decreases the > cap will move back down. The string may or may not follow it, depending on > what you believe - another point of discussion. If the cap material is not > strong enough (hard enough) then when the cap moves up the string will > indent itself into the cap and will not move up. When the cap moves back > down the string will not be able to follow it because the angle of the > indentation at the edge of the notch is now greater than the angle that the > string makes with the bridge, so there is a gap. Exactly, said angle being easily observed as in the photo I posted.. > I think what is causing the severe indentations is the process of > repeatedly tapping the strings down over the years. The bridge goes > through some number of humidity cycles which causes an indentation. The > tech comes along in the dry cycle and taps the strings down. The next wet > cycle the cap crushes some more. And on it goes. So, not only is tapping > the strings down a temporary fix, it's making matters worse in the long run. I agree, and tapping in bridge pins would be even worse.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC