Ed, Have you checked how this works out installed in the action? It seems to me you would want brand-new hammers to understrike by just a little with and eye towards wear-in. If it under-strikes by 1/16" after the hammers are filed to the final voiced size they won't under-strike with the first hammer reshaping. One plus for the negative. ;-) Andrew At 02:40 PM 11/17/2006, you wrote: >List, > >I am installing new butts, shanks, and hammers into an old Knabe >upright. The replacement butts I bought are Tokiwa. I didn't think >much about the fact that these butts are made in Japan, and Knabe is >an American upright. The "actual size" photo of this particular >Tokiwa butt in the catalog matched best with the old Knabe butts >that I am replacing. > >However, the one dimension you cannot see in the photos of the >catalogs is the exact location that the shank hole is bored into the >butts- they only show a profile. Herein lies the nature of my question: > >I lined a new Tokiwa butt and shank up in the action, side by side, >next to the old butt/shank/hammer. It turns out that the placement >of the shank-hole in the new Tokiwa butt is a little over 1/16th of >an inch closer to the strings than the old butt. This puts the >hammer and shank at a different pitch resting on the hammer rail, >and more importantly at impact with the strings. > >With these new butts, the hammer will make impact with the strings >just BEFORE is reaches a 90 degree angle (assuming the original >geometry of the butt/shank/hammer to string dimensions did so). Will >this be a problem????? > >Your input is greatly appreciated. >Ed > >_________________________________________________________________ >Get FREE company branded e-mail accounts and business Web site from >Microsoft Office Live >http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/mcrssaub0050001411mrt/direct/01/
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC