need some opinions

[David Skolnik]

Seems like the pills could use a bit wider distribution.  For a 
relatively short thread, there's a lot going on here.  Of only minor 
interest is the number of people who actively chose to include Ms. 
Jones in their replies. This, in and of itself, reflects either some 
fundamental technical ineptitude or a  dis-ease with the 
process.  Even Les's subsequent posts did not copy her, so I think 
that, while commendable in intent, the direct 'cc' impulse was a bit 
misguided, and a gamble.   It's one thing to engage in a conversation 
here, which allows, in theory, reflection, reconsideration, and 
growth.  Its another to be asked to effectively supply an endorsement.

As Barbara57 pointedly pointed out, the issues became clouded - 
environmental conditions, unreasonable expectations of the client, 
varying technical skills, varying tuning techniques, communication, 
etc.  Not knowing Les personally, I think his rather sarcastic reply 
to her haiku-esque post should inform my impression of him as much as 
his web-site.  How was she, or any of us to know the nature of his 
relationship with the client?

Maybe Matthew Todd is correct that, perhaps Ron should have waited 
for an explanation from Les before pressing 'launch'.  Here is what 
the basic question would look like:

>  are [you] trying to sell the concept that having techs other than 
> you tuning the pianos will ruin them?


David Skolnik
Hastings on Hudson, NY







At 11:44 PM 7/5/2008, Les Bartlett wrote:
>Oh, for your edification, I strongly recommended the lady write to 
>Ron, whose work and opinions i value highly.  I would be very please 
>if she did so.  No the "other guy" did not file or voice the 
>hammers, nor did he touch the really bad regulation, just did a 
>horrible tuning.  So thanks for your friendly repast, your support 
>for a toooner with a very good reputation for high quality work and 
>integrity- but I suppose no one checked my web site to find what 
>other significant musicians have felt about it.  Nah- it's not worth 
>it. Why mess up perfectly set opinions.
><http://www.bartlettpianoservice.com>www.bartlettpianoservice.com. 
>Any positive things in there have to be lies or accidents, for sure.
>thanks again
>lb
>
>David Ilvedson wrote:
>>
>>Yeah, I don't see the ruining the pianos part either...but Les's 
>>partner in crime might really like file new hammers to get the voicing right...
>>Ron, did you take your pill today?
>>
>>David Ilvedson, RPT
>>Pacifica, CA  94044



-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/20080706/56e9a583/attachment-0001.html