If you move the axis forward in line with the damper lever centers the bulk of the weight of the assembly moves toward the rear and the tray will almost want to tilt backwards left to its own devices. Thus the addition of a second spring is necessary. I find something intuitively wrong with this set up. It does seem to work more smoothly because there is less weight bearing on the pedal. It also forces the addition of spring resistance in place of actual weight. I'm not sure that's a better system. **** I tend to agree. I believe that lift lever/damper return springs also contributes to this - if you use them. It is easy enough to get the tray to return with one spring but the second one or a slightly stronger one gets the lost motion. Its like the single tray coil return spring comes to equalibrium with the damper/lift lever return springs just at the point where the dampers come to rest on the strings. I believe that the nature of the replacement kit is partly to blame for this - not that the kit is made wrong, it is just made wrong for this sort of application. I hear that the new parts maker will soon market one and it may be more frendly for this sort of thing. Gene
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC