I have heard the glue line argument from others against the use of horizontally laminated bridge caps because of the barrier of the glue line. I'm not equipped with the knowledge or scientific tools to advance the argument on either side. But I would follow up what Del said where in testing they couldn't hear the difference between the three kinds of caps by saying that - if the glue lines do indeed interrupt or distort the movement of the vibratory energy, such changes to the patterns of movement are insignificantly small at best and inaudible (if we are to believe Del and Baldwin's testing). As such, the most we can say about this glue line argument is that it is no more than trivially true and therefore of no practical consideration in the real making of piano bridges. And other considerations such as consistency and tuning stability can reasonably be held to be far more important if one is choosing between a horizontal cap or other methods. We regularly hear people asserting that they can hear the influence of certain materials or particular aspects of a design in a piano. I think it is true that for some things that we can. (say the effects of excessive downbearing for example). But it is also true that it is damn difficult to isolate the effect of a particular element from everything else that is influencing the tone, and there's the rub. Will -----Original Message----- From: pianotech-bounces at ptg.org [mailto:pianotech-bounces at ptg.org] On Behalf Of John Delacour Sent: Tuesday, September 21, 2010 3:45 AM To: pianotech at ptg.org Subject: Re: [pianotech] YC Capo Bars At 22:48 -0500 20/9/10, Ron Nossaman wrote: >...The string moves the bridge, and the bridge moves the soundboard, >which moves all the strings, etc. The less one dwells on presumed >mystical vibrational energy waves, the closer one gets to observed >and measurable results... On your side you have the Flat Earth Society and maybe the Pope; on the other the whole body of scientific literature concerning mechanical elasticity and acoustics. JD
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC