Thanks Tom and a nice story to go with it. Newton McNeilTom@aol.com wrote: > > I agree whole-heartedly with Newton, who as usual says it best! > > The most serious confrontation of my 30 years in this career came with the > chair of our piano faculty over a similar issue. In this case, we did have a > designated piano (ancient Knabe concert grand) for 'alternative performance > practices'. The chair of the piano faculty wanted to use instead the primary > S&S 'D' "just this once" since she was to be the pianist, and it was a > significant ensemble performance, etc. I said, "No," and we had previously > arranged that these calls were mine to make. I said that if she insisted on > overriding my call, I would reluctantly resign my responsibility for enforcing > the Piano Use Policy from that point forward. (This was a responsibility she > was loathe to resume.) > > In the end, the winning consideration was that her example, in either using > the 'designated piano' or the Steinway, would have far-reaching consequences. > We had about 55 piano majors at that time, and it was assumed that nearly all > of them would be in attendance for this particular performance. To her, the > prospect of, say 10%, of them wanting to use the Steinway for alternative > performance practices was most unwelcome. > > A few days after our initial very heated confrontation over this issue, we met > by chance in the mailroom. She gave me a warm hug of apology and our > relationship was wonderfully collegial from that day until the end of my > career there. She had been very impressed by the sincerity and tenacity of my > concern for the pianos under my care (and her use). > > The well-being of the pianos in your care should be your concern, and may be > your responsibility. Be professional and assertive on this, but try not to > loose your cool as I almost did! > > - Tom McNeil - > Vermont Piano Restorations > > In a message dated 99-03-05 18:47:58 EST, Newton wrote: > > << Tell the department chair about the potential damage to the instrument > and ask him to require the artist to be responsible for any such. I > did that once, the artist wanted to put tacks in the hammers. I hit > the roof and the chair agreed with me and suggest they rent their own > piano for such abuse. > > I HATE this kind of shit. > > Newton >>
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC