I dont really qualify, outside of attending this years S&S university environment technical seminar at Oberlin where I had the chance to talk at length with the fellow in the administration of Oberlin who is in charge. A kind of VP general authority position. And of course I had plenty of chances to talk with both the techs that work at Oberlin and others that work at other Steinway Schools. To begin with... nothing is perfect... nor even close. Buying all Steinway products does not mean you are going to be relieved of having to do any real work. And a good dean with the will to look after the schools interests in their half of the <<Bargain>> is definitely a plus. That said I'd have to say that the alternatives out there, at least the ones I have seen... are in far worse condition. That is to say Universities in general have problems maintaining and purchasing instruments well. Hell, far too many if not most schools dont even have a clear idea what piano techs do... and dont really care... its money out and thats as far as it goes. Collage schools with a hopscotch collection of gawd knows what abound and I think we all know what thats like. To be sure tho... there are some non-alligned schools that have very good technical maintainence programs and are very conscious about what they buy. Sauter was mentioned by Andrew... interesting as they too are a very pricey instrument that are delivered often as not very rough. I have lots of experience with Sauters over here of course. Nice pianos tho... as Steinways... nice in the sense that if you work with them you can bring out so very much fine piano sound and performance. At our school we have 2 S&S C's 2 B's (one a quite old NY), and a Boston 218 G, Boston 126U and 132U. The Bostons hold up quite well. Way better then some of the other size comparable instruments we have. A notable exception is a 25 year old Bluthner that was purchased for Leif Ove Andsnes when he was a student here. That piano has ages wonderfully. As as a Bechstein C we have. Most of the other grands could easily be junked at this point... tho perhaps a few of them could warrant a full redesign / rebuild. We have talked about becomming an all Steinway school... and brought it up at a recent visit by the regional sales rep from Hamburg. It is our understanding that no such school exists in Europe... that this is an American thing. We are looking into the possibilities of establishing the first such school here. If we manage it.... all our non-Steinway inventory will have to leave our ownership... including a rather ok CF III that is 4 years old now. All in all... for better and for worse... I'd have to say that the All Steinway School stamp is one that is very very much worth the dark sides of any such marriage is bound to have. Cheers RicB hi folks I'd be interested to hear experiences from those techs. working at schools that have become ''All Steinway''. Is it very restrictive on the purchase choice of instruments. What happened to existing inventory. Was administration and faculty won over by becoming ''All Steinway''. How are the Boston pianos holding up etc etc..........
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC