I agree David.
Using partial ratios for this kind of discussion makes things much
easier to relate to. One gets very specific real quick.
Cheers
RicB
This discussion of wide and narrow stretch is difficult using plain
English.
Frankly RCT stretch numbers are to me just as obscure. We can discuss
particulars in terms of partial ratios (4:2, 8:4 etc.) and that is a
little
more revealing. Or if one at least has an ETD of some kind we can
talk of
the stretch of C8 in numbers. For example in tuning a Steinway "D"
my C8
ends up at 43.92 cents and on a "B" 34.76 cents. That means
something to
me. I've heard of people using a stretch that gets to 75 cents at
C8 and
that seems pretty s-t-r-e-t-c-h-e-d to me.
Revealing where C8 ends up might make this a little clearer.
dave
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC