Inre actions suffering catastropic action failure,
Ric writes:
>>one thing nearly all replies have alluded to is a
situation where the shank is resting on the cushion.... and at the same
time resulting in a condition where the jack can not get under the
knuckle if it was not already under there to begin with.<>two problems.
First... the jack is supposed to be
under the knuckle well before the the shank even gets close to the rest
position after play. If it doesnt.. then either the rep lever spring is
too weak, or the center may be to tight.. or the jack is regulated too
far out... similar things.<<
Any action will fail to repeat if the second note is struck before the
key resets under the knuckle. There is a minimun distance the key must be
allowed to rise before the reset. If the key is struck before this minimum
distance is achieved, the jack will either skip or will not touch the knuckle, at
all. On a normal action, this is just a one time failure and as soon as the
key is allowed up, the note will once again repeat.
On an action in which the hammershank cushion is too far below the
hammer's resting position, the skip, (cited above) allows the hammershank to fall
so far that the capstan is holding the whippen too high for the jack to
reset. In other words, the knuckle is below the lowest jack height possible.
Hence, a note that doesn't play until the hammershank is bounce up into the jack's
range.
( I hope that makes sense...)
<< The rep lever is supposed to lift the hammer
via the knuckle up to a position where the jack can slip under as soon
as (nearly immediatly after) the key is released. >>
I must respectfully disagree. The purpose of the rep lever is to
increase the speed of the key return. We measure the spring strength by watching
the hammer rise, but in rapid repetition, that event doesn't occur. Under
fast repetition, the hammer shank doesn't rise between blows, but rather, stays
at checking distance while the key and whippen, (under the influence of the
spring), return to their "reset" position. One can ascertain this for
themselves by playing middle C so that the hammer is held in check, and then slowly
depressing B3 so that the hammer is at drop. Simultaneously, release both keys
and observe that the C return far, far more rapidly than the B.
One can also see, on an action model, that when the key is released
while the hammer is held in check, the hammer doesn't rise, but rather, drops to
its at rest position. Under high speed conditions, there is no time for the
hammer to rise between notes.
This is why there is no difference in repetition speed between a spring
that slams the hammer off the jack when released and a spring that simple
lifts the hammer as fast as possible without being felt in the key. Unfortunately,
many regulators destroy the sensitivity of escapement by pursuing the former
course in the mistaken belief that it improves repetition. Checking height
has far more effect on repetition speed than anything else.
Regards,
Ed Foote RPT
http://www.uk-piano.org/edfoote/index.html
www.uk-piano.org/edfoote/well_tempered_piano.html
<BR><BR><BR>**************************************<BR> See what's free at
http://www.aol.com.</HTML>
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC