On Wed, 07 Nov 2007 08:42:32 +0100
Richard Brekne <ricb at pianostemmer.no> wrote:
> Ah, a post what puts a finger closer to the core of the
>present tangent to this debate. It has been amazing to
>see how so many have dodged around the more holistic
>pictures here to bang through individual points which
>regardless of their validity or not are rather
>meaningless in themselves. We do need to keep it
>friendly tho .. :)
Hi Ric,
You are right, I did get a little carried away in the
emphasis department. Apologies to the list for
flaming. OTOH, there are occasionally times when a
little yelling is justified, IMO. Nothing personal
towards Jeff, whom I respect and consider a friend (and
hope the feeling is mutual), but a blatant falsehood needs
to be challenged or we cant have a productive
conversation. I view the statement I quoted as equivalent
to a claim that someone who passed the RPT tuning exam has
merely shown the ability to sit in a room with a piano for
an hour and a half and make a slight improvement in its
tuning, and furthermore tuning ability is something you
are born with cant be taught or tested. Maybe we are
all entitled to our own opinion, but if we are to
contribute in a positive way to a conversation we have to
think at least a little bit about what we say, and keep it
within the boundaries of reality.
I know that Jeff has a tendency to overstate his
case, to use hyperbole in argument. I can live with that,
but there are limits. I still cant stand by and let a
statement like this pass unchallenged:
Someone who holds a music degree has merely demonstrated
that they can absorb material long enough to regurgitate
it on an exam, and that they have shown some degree of
incremental improvement in musical ability over a 2 or 4
year period, that they have attended a certain number of
performances per term and have been present and accounted
for in at least one performing ensemble each term.
I have my own healthy share of cynicism towards
degrees and educational programs, but I also have decades
of experience watching freshmen become graduates (and my
own experience as a college student, both undergraduate
and masters). I know with absolute certainty they did more
than that. At least in my institution, and I dont think
UNM is among the top music schools in the country.
Now as to whether a music degree is necessary or
desirable for a caut, that is another question. I like
Alan Eders attitude:
I have found the value of my own years studying music vis
a vis working in a conservatory environment is
understanding the language (which one can get on one's
own) but, moreover, having a high degree of empathy for
what the the students and faculty are experiencing as
performers and composers in a school setting.
The empathy and understanding of what is going on in
the school or department is extremely valuable. Necessary,
maybe not, but helpful, yes. Should a PTG CAUT endorsement
include requiring a college degree of any sort? Id say
no. Let the institution require it if they choose. We
should focus on technical chops in working on pianos, and
knowledge in appropriate areas (organization, etc).
Regards,
Fred Sturm
University of New Mexico
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC