Jeff: As I've said before I'm really sorry that your situation at USC was such a negative thing. I don't have that at my school and I'm certainly glad. The head technician at the local Steinway Hall told me recently that I had the best CAUT job because of the people I work with. I had to agree. They all are truly wonderful human beings who happen to be excellent musicians. They treat me with respect and collegiality. I know that this is because of who they are rather than who I am but there are places where this is true. It does take a certain number of good people to create a good culture. Fortunately for me we have that critical mass of good people. dave David M. Porritt, RPT dporritt at smu.edu -----Original Message----- From: caut-bounces at ptg.org [mailto:caut-bounces at ptg.org] On Behalf Of Jeff Tanner Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 2008 4:39 PM To: caut at ptg.org Subject: Re: [CAUT] Faculty as Colleagues, was Steinway... The "Safe" Piano. Rick Florence wrote: "We are as involved in the musical process as most faculty. It is to our advantage to be considered colleagues as opposed to staff. We have more to offer than solely the service of pianos." Now, Rick, You and I and most of the rest of us understand and agree with that. But the music faculty most certainly do not, and never will. "If we allow ourselves to be marginalized by not participating in such important decisions, we put ourselves in the position of being thought of as nothing more than piano mechanics." Unfortunately, I'm afraid the music faculty puts us there without any effort or lack thereof on our part. "For a group that constantly complains about the lack of pay and respect in our profession, we sure have a strange way of enabling such a position by assuming such a benign existence." This, I agree with 100%. But the down to earth reality is that until there is a university degree that awards a doctorate in piano technology (which would be about the silliest example of diminishing returns we could endeavor to create), I'm afraid that we will always be looked at as mere custodians by those who have the doctoral degrees. It is a sad thing to say, but those degrees are about the only thing that gives many academic types their self worth, and with them they create their own little disengaged world where anyone else who doesn't have one doesn't belong. The reality about lack of pay and respect in our profession is that academic musicians with doctoral degrees are our glass ceiling and they're not working for much more. Just let one of them find out that that lowly piano tuner is making more than they are. I later found out that when I was initially hired at USC, the junior piano faculty with a doctorate found out I got a couple thousand more than he was making (which was a pittance) and he created quite a ruckus. It didn't matter that with his position there was opportunity for advancement whereas with mine there was not. It was all about that degree. That is the biggest reason I got out. There was no way to ever move up. Jeff Tanner
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC