While Mr. Scherer's research may not be well controlled, I believe it has produced results which are very accurate. I present the following: 1. My mother is a piano teacher, and has been for 30+ years. She can easily tell you which students have good or bad instruments in the home by the progress of the student. Exceptions are rare. I can't tell you how many examples she has given of students who play the right notes and then say "that's not right" or "my piano doesn't sound like yours". But do you think the parent will even spring to have the piano tuned (much less purchase a better one) unless the child shows any progress? (They've never called me, at least) 2. A very close friend of mine who is one of the most magnificent musicians I have ever heard perform, hated piano when he was young. He didn't like the sound of them. At the age of 12 he turned to the organ and is now a concert/church organist who is in much demand. The pianos he was exposed to when young were PSO spinets and an occasional old worn out grand. When he got to college he was then exposed to better concert quality instruments and has since made the statement that had he known that this was what a piano was supposed to sound like, he may never have made the switch. He and I both have the same belief: Those parents who buy their children junk to see how they progress before they will invest in a good piano are programming their children to fail before they begin. They are at least telling their child that they aren't going to invest any more in the lessons than they have to...why should the child? We also both believe that children have better musical ears than we do. That child isn't going to want to practice on an "instrument" he/she doesn't like the sound of, or the feel of for that matter. Neither of us has controlled research to prove this. But having been exposed to listening to thousands of piano lessons in my 32 years through the walls of my home, as well as taking part in music programs of almost every nature alongside hundreds of different people from all walks of life from childhood through college and beyond, it doesn't take controlled research (you don't have to be a rocket scientist) to come to this conclusion. Have a great weekend. jt Jeff Tanner, Piano Technician School of Music University of South Carolina Columbia, SC 29208 (803)-777-4392 (phone) (803)-777-6508 (fax)
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC