All of the discussion of temperments inspired me to pick up a very good book I found browsing in the bookstore: Lies My Music Teacher Told Me : Music Theory for Grownups by Gerald Eskelin [ I got it locally at Barnes&Noble for $14.95 -- you can save $2.99 and get it from <http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ISBN%3D1886209111/readqqcombooks04A/3483-0850188-572451> but you'll probably pay it again in shipping. ] Mr. Eskelin teaches music theory and choral singing, and coaches the Los Angeles Jazz Choir. He has many comments on temperments -- he happens to believe that many beginning singers have been ruined by learning with piano accompaniment. ( He does note that one of the basics a good accompanist learns is NOT to play the melody behind the singer, so as not to tempt the singer to follow his pitch. ) I don't know if advocates of HT can mine any useful ammunition from this book. It *IS* a good explaination, but clearly no HT comes close to what Mr. Eskelin would like to see, which would be a complete *dynamic* temperment -- i.e. a keyboard that does what a good singer or string player does -- changes the pitch of notes depending on their immediate harmonic role. Does anyone happen to know if this has been done on any digital keyboards ? Are there any dynamic tuning MIDI programs for keyboad ? ( BTW: is there an archive of HT MIDI programs on the net somewhere ? ) - Steve Majewski
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC