<<http://www.io.com/~hmiller/music/music.html>> I went to the above site this morning as was suggested and listened to the selections there. Now, I have promised not to be inflammatory on this List and this is not meant to be. But, I must say that I got a very distinct case of nausea while listening to some of these selections. This is a purely clinical observation, mind you. Maybe it's just me, but I really don't like synthesizers or electronic keyboards of any kind. I have often heard people suggest using them to demonstrate various kinds of temperaments but I really do not agree that this is a good way. You must have a real piano, fortepiano, harpsichord or pipe organ to get real music, in my opinion. A synthesizer produces "sythesized" (read artificial or imitation) music. Some claim that there are some of these instruments that are so good that you really can't tell but I always and surely can and I don't like the sound. The whole idea of using Historical Temperaments of the different eras is to recreate the sound that musicians and composers actually heard in their lifetimes. The kinds of theoretical tunings heard on this site are supposed to be "futuristic", I suppose. If so, I am glad that I probably won't be around long enough to have to get used to hearing them on any kind of regular basis. Moreover, I predict, with no shame at all, that they never will become popular, just as Atonal and Serial music never became popular as early 20th Century composers thought. Of all the kinds of music that people typically listen to today, they are all tonal and many of them use only a very limited part of the available harmony of the keyboard. Indeed, many use only three chords. So why do we need 18 or 22? It just seems to go against the way the mind works (not to mention the stomach). I am a widower of nearly 4 years now but my 22 year old son comes over often to visit and use the computer. I decided to ask his opinion, thinking he might be more open minded. These were his very words: "That doesn't sound like what you do or talk about, Dad, your pianos sound perfectly in tune, that just sounds like sour grapes to me!" So, if it's all right with everyone else or even if it isn't, I'll continue to explore and develop the Equal Beating Victorian Temperament and other Equal Beating Well Tempered and *mild* Meantone temperaments. They are what makes traditional music sound the way it was intended and the most pleasant to my ear and to that of my customers. In less than a month, September 21, I will demonstrate this temperament style to the Chicago Chapter and Virgil Smith will demonstrate ET. I expect the debate to be lively and results to interesting. Tomorrow, I tune again at the Frank Lloyd Wright estate for the 33 year old Dutch composer and pianist, Sebastien Huydts who now resides in Chicago. He will play both traditional and his own music in the EBVT. I expect the temperament to first of all, make his piano sound very much in tune with itself and secondly to enhance the music, not make it sound sour or weird. I believe that my goals are in line with most other HT tuning piano technicians as well. I really don't know anyone who does these experimental kinds of tunings and who has any kind of an appreciative audience. Bill Bremmer RPT Madison, Wisconsin
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC