Hi list... just in case anyone is interested in this project of mine, I thought I might describe my observations so far as they might be instructive to others on my same path, and interesting for those who may have already tread this way. I started scratching my head almost at once when I started to line up the spread. Nothing added up. And ratios measure by length or by weight seemed just plain wacky compared to what I have been able to find in old journal reprints, and information provided with the Standwood kit. Examples... alligning the spread to the existing magic line results in the jack center to be about 5 mm behind (wide spread) of the perpendicular to the hammer shank at the knuckle core. Alligning the spread to conform to this "perpendicular rule" results in the magic line to be about 2 mm low of the present point of contact for the capstand and whippen cushion. My key ratio is rather high on this thing so I have concluded that it has to be moved in. At present its about .60 and I want it down to at least .55 This means moveing both the whippen and the capstan towards the front about 10-12 mm, which also means that the magic line calls for an even lower contact point. So the whippen cushions are going to need to be a bit longer. At present they are 15 mm including the felt, and I will replace with 20 mm. My objective is to get as close to the 9.0 gram Whippen Balance Weight Stanwood specifies as I can. (Key Ratio times the Whippen Radius Weight), and at the same time insure that the Key ratio lifts the whippen just enough at a 10 mm key dip so that the jack just clears the knuckle at lettoff / drop when these are at their proper adjustments. Another thing I bumped into on this thing is what seems to be a long hammer shank ratio. The shank is 132 mm from centerpin to center molding, with the center to knuckle at 16.8 This pushes the shank ration close to 8 (7.86~ to 1). This seems a bit high, but I havent thought through what this means yet... grin. All in all, it looks like to me that this action was set up origionally in a pretty helter skelter fashion. I have a hard time imagining what criteria they use to set the spread, but it seems like they had a balance pin position, and simply pushed the whippen to a position where you could draw a line straight through the bottom middle of the whippen cushion to the center pin of the whippen flange, and put the capstan right underneath the whippen middle line. Who knows.. Anyways.. your comments are welcome appreciated for sure.. This is my first attempt at all this, and I feel definately like I am way out on a pretty thin branch.. If worst comes to worst... I suppose I will have to eat this one big time... grin. -- Richard Brekne RPT, N.P.T.F. Bergen, Norway
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC