Not Enough Scientific Analysis (somewhat non-technical)

[David Ilvedson]

Are we catching up on old stuff or what?

David I.


-----Original Message-----
From: owner-pianotech@ptg.org [mailto:owner-pianotech@ptg.org]On Behalf
Of Rob Kiddell
Sent: Wednesday, August 30, 2000 7:53 AM
To: pianotech@ptg.org
Subject: Re: Not Enough Scientific Analysis (somewhat non-technical)


Mr. Simon, 

Finally the source of your rant slides into focus.

You are less concerned about the effects of fabric softener on 
hammers than you are about the lack of scientific analysis on any 
piano technical procedures.

If a procedure is documented enough, can it slowly be accepted as 
a standard in the piano technical field?

In August 1997, I wrote an article for the Journal about bridle strap 
function that contained a glaring error, that was immediately seized 
upon by Jim Ellis, RPT in a letter in the following issue. Not 
content with the letter, Jim conducted an experiment which he 
published in the December '97 Journal that conclusively proved his 
point. It was also written in classic scientific experimental format: 
Introduction, Historical Background, Experimental Data, 
Conclusion and References. The results were fascinating and a 
clear example of 'gold medal' writing.

My point: If you are greatly agitated by the lack of experimental 
data regarding fabric softener and hammers, (and by the volume 
and tone of your posts, I assume this is a matter that weighs upon 
you), there are at least 5 different types of hammers and an entire 
laundry aisle of fabric softeners, we eagerly await your publication. 

Also, why are you concerned with extreme hammer voicing 
methods on 90 year old pianos that will never have their hammers 
changed? I assume the owners don't have the means to replace a 
set of hammers, or these hammers are of such a precious variety 
that they can never be sullied with undocumented voicing 
techniques. 

Eagerly awaiting your response, 


Rob Kiddell RPT
Atonal Piano Service
http://www.telusplanet.net/public/atonal/