Bill, Yep, that's the origin, all right, but if we now consider it an English word, there is no standard spelling, because no authoritative decision has been made in this regard. I prefer to ditch the "h" out of respect for the origin, but the word appears in no standard dictionary, which is pretty astounding if you ask me. I don't know of any other entire word (not merely a usage or definition) that has been around 150 years and yet escaped the Oxford English Dictionary. (I sent them an e-mail but got no response.) Paul S. Larudee, RPT Richmond, CA Billbrpt@AOL.COM wrote: > It came to light a few years ago (and was written up in the Journal) that the > word which has most often been spelled, "whippen" comes from a German verb > (not the name of an object but a word describing an action) which means "to > rock", "wippen". In German, the "W" is pronounced as a "V" is in English, so > the word in German sounds like "Vippen". > > Many words used in Piano Technology came out of factories in which there were > people using mixtures of language. An example would be the German makers and > craftsmen who went to England, the United States and Canada. Somehow, the > English speaking workers and the Germans would learn to understand each > other, each learning a bit of the other's language. > > The present day thinking is that this word should be spelled, "Wippen" but it > is also recognized that the word has often been spelled with the "h" > inserted. The abbreviation, "Whips" is also commonly used to refer to a set > of them. It would seem to me that if "Wippen" is correct, then a good > abbreviation for a set of them would be, "Wips", not "Whips", although I > have never seen the word, "Wips" in print. > > Bill Bremmer RPT > Madison, Wisconsin
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC