>>Compared to sound board replacement, yes. Compared to using Roger Jolly's
>>prelude to voicing techniques, no.
>
>I have great respect for Roger and his techniques for voicing.
>However, I do think that Wapin and Roger's techniques address
>different things. Perhaps Roger is reading this and would care to
>weigh in?
>
Hi Jon,
Voicing is working with what is in front of you, making the
best out off what you have. It's not going to help much with a dead board
other that smooth a few notes out, that may need some crown needling. Same
goes for Wapin, It will not make a bad board, or rolled bridge sound good.
Installing a new board, or Wapin, is up grading the instrument, as opposed
to just servicing it.
Having said that, Installing a new board, Wapin, or renotching curved
bridge lines. It what I call radical voicing. Because it should make a
big difference in tone quality, if done correctly. <G>
Roger
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC