><<"A soundboard isn't in any way the surface of a balloon.">> > >Never said it was exactly...... what I 'did' say was "The analogy ain't >perfect but merely a reasonable facsimile :-)" No, that's the point. It isn't a reasonable facsimile. The skin of the balloon isn't the driving mechanism, where the panel of the soundboard is. They're entirely different. >And the top surface of a soundbaord does expand and contract. as does the >surface of a ballon...if'n it didn't?............. how doe the sucker gain >and lose crown?....Or form "pressure ridges"? Or accumulate "compression >damage"? Because wood changes dimension with humidity changes, and these dimensional changes drive the entire process. You see, in most parts of the world, the humidity isn't a steady 99% all the time so this may be a regional concept. That's the key point that must be understood before any of this other stuff makes sense. >"arch buttresses do not form or maintain" anything either they merely hold >something in place by providing resistance.....anything held in place by a >"buttress" will react to that "buttress" within the limits of that "butress" >and the characteristics of the material being held. If you take your flat >ribbed ,flat paneled, sounboard and stick it in your hot box and 'not' >restrain it in some way after it is taken out.....all you will have is a flat >board that basically gets hotter and cooler 'without much' change vis a vis >crown. I know what a buttress does, and the ribs are the constraining element. Once again, the assembly is crowned and will support a considerable load before it is ever put into the rim. The rim does not support crown - the ribs and panel compression do. >......... the archives show just as much dis-cohesiveness of >"the extensive and voluminously detailed discussions" and thoughts as they >did originally and are displaying currently. :-) >Jim Bryant (FL) Only where folks have refused to accept basic principals of physics. This stuff is provable by demonstration any time you care to try it. Ron N
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC