naphtha + mineral oil / silicon + naphtha

Ritchiepiano@AOL.COM Ritchiepiano@AOL.COM
Sun, 9 Sep 2001 21:42:32 EDT


In a message dated 9/9/01 12:59:29 PM Eastern Daylight Time, 
owner-pianotech-digest@ptg.org writes:

<< 
 7. The silicon as used by both Baldwin and Wurlitzer is one of the safest 
products in the technicians arsenal of chemicals. The MSDS sheet indicates no 
harmful effects from swallowing, skin absorption,  inhalation, and skin 
 contact. Even eye contact is listed as "may cause minor irritation and 
swelling of the conjunctivae". It will not aggravate existing medical 
conditions. The flash point is 390 degrees F so it is safe in the trunk of a 
 car. The vapor density is listed as HEAVIER THAN AIR. (brings into question 
the "traveling uphill" suspicians). 
 ------------------------------ >>
List,
Now, as for the Silicon.  You are confusing the element Silicon with
silicone or silicone rubber. I think this topic has been breached before.

Webster's says:

silicon: a tetravalent nonmetallic element that occurs combined as the most
abundant element next to oxygen in the earth's crust and is used especially
in alloys.

silicone:  any of various polymeric organic silicon compounds obtained as
oils, greases, or plastics and used esp. for water-resistant and heat
resistant lubricants, varnishes, binders, and electric insulators

silicone rubber:  rubber made from silicone elastomers and noted for its
retention of flexibility, resilience, and tensile strength over a wide
termperature range.

What we are talking about is silicone.  Heavier than
air isn't really the question.  Frequently (almost always) oils, greases,
plastics and rubbers are not pure compounds, but mixtures. They can
contain other components such as antioxidants, plasticizers, etc.
which do, in fact, volatilize out of the silicone and can deposit on
something else. Volatile compounds can come out of, say, 
a car dashboard and coalesce onto the car window,
( it's that new car smell) or out of a CD jewel case onto a CD. 
If you really think that something came out of the silicone and 
deposited on something else, IT COULD HAVE.  The problem is
that you don't really know what is in the silicone (and by the way, Baldwin
probably doesn't either).  If you have been sensitized to something, you can
react to it and they wouldn't necessarily have to put it on the MSDS.

WD-40, according to the company and a 25 year rep. says it has never
contained "silicone" . They did produce a product under a different name
that did. The sales representative however did not recommend WD-40 
for use on wooden parts and I wouldn't either. FWIW

Mark Ritchie RPT


This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC