Today was the day, and the subject was a new 6' Pearl River. Following the instructions(aural) available on Bill's website, I was able to fashion what seemed to be something other than ET, and it worked. There were a couple of keys that I question my own twisting and turning of pins: The key of B was, let's say, active...and the key of Ab was not quite as active. Seeing that this was my first attempt at something other than ET(aurally), I will give myself the benefit of the doubt and say that perhaps I didn't have 1 or 2 notes set quite right. I'm not questioning the instructions on the site..rather my own judgement calls on setting the temperament. What I liked: -The 'simpler' keys of C, F, G, D and even Eb sounded smoother and cleaner. -Using the "Expanded Octaves" that came with the instructions, I really like how the top end sounded, but I question the bass beyond the tenor break. -I'm not much of a classical player, but the opening passage of "Clair De Lune" sounded just fine..my chops are geared more towards Jazz, and my impressions of Bill Evans sounded fine. -I'll try this again to see if I can get the Key of B to sound better than it did. What I didn't like: -no one to critique me..if there's no one around to say this note or that note is set incorrectly, then I am left to make my own judgement calls..not necessarily a bad thing, but there's always someone out there who knows more than you, and that's where I'm coming from. - I didn't necessarily like how the Bass sounded, but that could be the result of my own faulty judgement calls. I'll try it again, because it was fun, different, and an aural challange. -Phil Bondi (Fl.) tito@philbondi.com
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC