---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
In a message dated 11/23/2002 10:00:34 AM Pacific Standard Time,
pianobuilders@olynet.com writes:
Del writes
> It is my practice to set the rim and bellyrail, including the soundboard
> cutoff rail, flat. Since the soundboard will be stressed -- i.e., have
> considerably less crown -- once the strings go on I prefer to have a flat,
> consistent mounting surface for the parameter of the board. Besides, my
> cutoff bars tend to be so shaped that very little of the soundboard is
> actually glued to the bellyrail.
>
> And, while we're on the subject, for the same reasons I fail to see any
> advantage to beveling the inner rim to (supposedly) accommodate the shape
> of the soundboard. It is claimed that this somehow aids the maintenance of
> crown but I surely don't see how. To illustrate simply clamp a piece of
> spruce to a bench and see how easily it is bent.
>
>
Del
Heresy and poppy cock. No just kidding . I just laid a straight
edge across the belly rail of an Stwy L and it has the stated approx. 1/4''
crown. While I can't see why this is necessary at least here it seems less
desireable,at least to me, to encourage any more undue stresses in the
system than it already has by introducing flat rastens as practice.
I.E. although you say the beveled rasten has no merit you certainly
wouldn't want it beveled in the opposite direction as the current industry
standard. To my way of thinking the beveled rasten is an engineering idea
that aids the board, albeit slightly, to resist the flattening of the board
under load. Recognizing that by in large most on the list are building rib
crowned boards that retain more of there crown when under load than the
former compression stlye boards. Rib crowned boards being much stiffer by
design, thanks to higher rib radii and stiffer spruce rib material (formerly
sugar pine) and deeper ribs. I have installed boards on flat rims and the
residual crown in the 2 I'm thinking of did turn out with less net crown than
usual.
I see nothing wrong with the beveled rim personally, if my boards are
retaining a good amount crown even when strung I see no reason to induce
another unnecessary possible strain at the edge of the board by changing all
the beveled rastens that come through the shop to a flat edge. No, I'm not
saying you were advocating that either.
Simply clamping a piece of spruce to a bench and bending it isn't exactly
like the continuos rim of board being glued to a curving rim. Gluing the
board to the rim gives the whole structure a cohesive stiffness it doesn't
have before that. Also the board is often thinned down to as little as .250
at the edges so undue stress once again not desired. The 1 and 1/2 degerees
typically found in the rim joint could as practicallity or compromise be
reduced to half that and this angle would more likely conform to the residual
crown angle after stringing.
Perhaps petty, lame and faulty thinking but it's mine all mine.
Dale Erwin
>
>
---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/4f/6f/3b/72/attachment.htm
---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment--
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC