Conrad, You asked: "Were there overdampers which worked well?" IMO you have totally lost the purpose of Over Dampers, in you rationale. Over Damper pianos were made side by side with modern style uprights. The manufacturers knew how to make an upright dampen to the standards we know today. They made the Over Damper pianos to simulate the SOUND of the "ancient instruments", (my terminology, which denotes the period of time when the technology and knowledge was not refined.), only louder. Most Over Damper pianos sound as they were intended. I truly wish that technicians would quit trying to compare them with modern instruments. It is incorrect to do so. Regards, Joe Garrett, RPT, (Oregon) Been There, Didn't Like It, So I'm Here To Stay! [G}
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC