---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
Ron
Beautiful post & description of the dilema of setting down bearing in the
real world that covers this practically. When I was just getting started in
the belly business I set up a Model A stwy to 11/2 degrees, calcluated
without strings & without pre compressing anything. The result was that by the
time I got the bottom half of the tenor strung my wonderful downbearing
calculations had disappeared in to the gradually compressing sound board so that by
the time I got to stringing the first capo there was zero degrees angle &
hence no down bearing pressure.
The resultant tonal failure could have been devastating but fortunately
I had used an adjust able plate suspension system & was able to do some fancy
adjusting & save the project without starting over. The information I used
to set up the boards/bearing came from an article in the journal, by the
way, & I later chastised my friend who wrote them for not amending them to
include pre-stressing the board method, which he also had since switched to. Be
careful what you read as the truth even in our own illustrious journal.
My compliments for providing some real numbers & math
Dale
A common scenario with new pianos is for techs to
measure a down bearing figure which on the face
of it looks OK, but very often the sound board
has sunken to a state where it is pushed almost
completely flat by the down bearing angle which
was set into the piano. In these instances the
board is too weak for down bearing loads which are
being applied or the unstrung angle wasn't set
properly. Either the down bearing unstrung angle
should be reduced or the board strengthened to
withstand the setting angles to which it is being
asked to resist. So often technicians will look
at a sound board and declare that it is fine
because the down bearing angle measures some
wonderful figure. But if the board has been
pushed inside out before the customer's ink is
dry on the cheque, things ain't too good,
regardless of what the down bearing gauge might
indicate.
Get an accurate down bearing gauge and a thread
length for looking at crown, and measure a few
pianos old and new. You'll develop a picture of
what's happening.
Ron O.
---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/a1/a1/62/30/attachment.htm
---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment--
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC