Steven.
Just a couple of points. Many here know pianos from the inside out and
there is not a lot that sneaks past attentions when it comes to tricks
of the trade. Your <<card trick>> comes in many varieties and is really
as old as the shift pedal I would think. As for your assessment of the
purpose of the soft pedal, well ... there are those who agree with its
name and there are those who line up with your view... either way its
cool. As for attacks for your "unscientific empirical and amature
methods".... piano techs have been listening heads up to pianists
experiences ever since we went our separate ways way back when. I rely
on pianists expressions of experience daily it sometimes seems. But
there are some established things thats been gone over and over, The
industry has by and large after some 150 + years of the more or less
modern piano come to be in agreement on many of these. If you recommend
something like timing dampers to start at the beginning of key stroke
for example, you can expect to hear disagreement... because if there is
such a thing as a <<wrong way of doing things>> in piano work... this
certainly falls into that catagory. Of course personal individual
preference can allow for a much wider window of acceptability then
standard practice... but then sometimes even these are way out on the
fringe.
I dont mean any discouragement with this. Quite the opposite really. But
then again, folks here were not born yesterday either. What you
personally find to work on your piano is dandy. But advice that goes
contrary to what is known as good practice will indeed get shot down...
not because anyone has a desire to attack you... but ... well because
wrong is wrong after all.
And yes.. Ketchup has some vinegar in it. When you copper into the
ketchup, the vinegar in the ketchup combines with the copper oxide (the
dirty looking stuff) to form a chemical called copper acetate. When you
wash it off with cold water the copper acetate dissolves, so you wind up
with a nice, bright shiny piece of copper. I think that one goes around
in science experiments for first year junior high or something like that.
Cheers
RicB
I am presenting this method with some trepidation, following a
proven successful personal experience. (I am not a technician, but a
classical pianist. After all, who has ever heard of a respectable
RPT using playing cards inside a piano !!!!!!!)
I have another good trick with cards to report, and some more quick
and dirty ideas but I will save them for later, if I survive the
attacks from my ‘unscientific empirical and amateur’ methods being
tested successfully on my two beloved grand pianos. (They have no
choice but to succumb to my surgery, fortunately with good results).
All the best
Steve
P.S. Is it true that ketchup cleans and restores copper?
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC