Hi Dale I think you are correct in that neither you or David... or for that matter throw in Ron and David Andersen and a couple more could at this point generate enough counter-inertia to force a change in corporate manufacturing... but who knows... stranger things have happened. And I am glad you dont care or find this objectionable for exactly the same reasons you state. The "subjective" by definition on the other hand can not be a matter of "better" or "worse" ... only what we / they / I / you / like more or less at any given time..... which also to my mind fits right in with the exciting new and innovative directions some rebuilders / builders are taking. Its the stuff the dynamics of our trade is made of. Presented in a positive enough and market wise smart enough fashion... if the resulting sounds created find a tone with enough of the buying public... then a paradigm shift is just around the corner. And if not...well hey... so what ? You all know you are making fine and wonderful sounding products that many musicians and listeners will have years of pleasure from... and thats the main thing. I guess I get hung up in this need to keep the subjective in its place because of a perception I have about comparisons in general. I dont like to compare my work to others.... and I simply cant deal with the idea of saying to anyone "I am better" or "my way is better"..... even in cases where I know there can be no doubt. I have my hands full every day comparing todays work with yesterdays... my own work... todays knowhow with yesterdays. Every second I spend comparing myself to somone else is time used doing something counterproductive in the first place and doing something other then getting farther down my own road in the second place. And when on top of it all I know the market is so darned fickle anyways.... exactly because of all the subjectiveness, magic, psychology,... all things not objective... well... it seems like there are better things to do then concern myself overly with these. Said another way, I <<compete>> with others as little as I possibly can get away with and as much with myself as I can possibly get myself to do. Seems to work well. Cheers RicB Ric Even if all my clients do like it & alll David's clients it will not change corporate manufacturing one iota & I don't care if it does, because then we wouldn't be offering anything different, new or exciting. You Know? But somewhere subjective becomes more better than something else otherwise we wouldn't tune or voice or breathe cause it would be .......well subjective. BTW , I respect dispassionate. Dale I do not buy Davids or Dales claim that it makes a qualitative /improvement/ because that is purely a matter of subjective taste... period. It makes a qualitative /change/ that some may like and some will not. And if enough do like it.. then it will make an impact that will cause a change in the industry. If not... well then it wont. Dispassionate as hell... but the bloody truth of the matter. Cheers RicB ************************************** See what's free at http://
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC