[CAUT] Carbon Fiber Soundboard

Richard Brekne ricb at pianostemmer.no
Mon Nov 26 09:55:03 MST 2007


Hi Terry..

Yes that Dream bit seemed a bit of an odd thing to me as well. It was 
the introduction to his presentation.  Have you ever played a Stuart 
yourself or listened to one up close and personal ?  I have heard 
several conflicting comments about this distortion thing.  I'd like to 
reserve judgment till I hear for myself. I have several recordings where 
they are really driven hard and I dont find anything I would call 
distortion.  Tho the sound is reminiscent of forte instruments of old 
and when driven hard do take on a much different quality then a modern 
instrument driven hard.

As for the Steinway bit. You have to remember this fellow is used to 
Hamburg Steinways.

In anycase his own instrument was quite satisfying.  Tho personally... I 
still dont find an instrument that in the end manages as much all around 
versatile good sound as Steinway and Sons.  Preference thing I guess.   
I love em myself.  Hamburgs mind you.

Cheers
RicB


    My Dream Piano.....
    The Power and Build Quality of a Stuart
    The Upper Register Sound of a Fazioli
    The Tenor and Bass Sound of a Bösendorfer
    The Artist / Keyboard Interface of a Steinway


    Have you ever listened to a Stuart? Maybe some would want to call
    what they
    have "power", but the pianos distort badly at any medium-lound volume.
    Keyboard of a Steinway? Maybe some, but taken as a whole, I'd hate
    to be
    producing pianos with that kind of inconsistency.

    Hmmmm....

    Terry Farrell



More information about the Pianotech mailing list

This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC