Hi Stéphane
Thanks for your reply. Have to think about it for a bit... bore length
dependent eh ? I've always taken for given that the bore length is equal
to the distance from the strings (at strike point) to the key bed minus
the distance of the hammer shank center to the key bed. That puts the
shank at horizontal at impact. Raking to make perpendicular to the
string with the shank at horizontal at impact would require the hammer
to be raked inwards yes ? Which means increasing the actual bore length
by the sin of the angle of the rake times the length of the
aforementioned formula and adjusting the length of the shank center to
middle of hammer molding accordingly. I see no way at all that an
outwards rake is compatible with that formula for bore length at the
same time being compatible with a requirement of hammer to string angle
being perpendicular.
The bore length formula could be easily enough modified to work given an
inwards rake. That would be (D1 - D2) * cos sin A where D1 is the
distance of the string to key bed, D2 is the distance between hammer
shank center and key bed and A is the angle between the key bed and the
string plane. Bore at that distance would require the center of the
molding to be moved out on the shank by a length equivalent to Sin A
times the resultant bore length in order to maintain the shank at
horizontal at impact while the hammer is perpendicular to the string.
Either way... somethings gotta give.. either hammer shank center to
center molding, hammer rake, or shank in horizontal at impact.
Strikes me off hand that shank being horizontal at impact is a
desirable, so if hammer rake is then to be decided by string angle then
floating the distance between hammer center and center molding seems to
be the only solution.
yes ??
RicB
Hi Ric.
Strings angle up to the bridge from the striking point so
anbackwards rake would just make the angle between hammer
and string atimpact even farther away from this stated optimal.
< Ar, depends on the bore length, not ? Do you use the dummy
spare hammers with known bore length trick to accurate the bore
length measure ? It shortcuts all measurements failures and
approximations, including the less than optimal keyboard frame
bedding and the said strings angle up (or down). I can't
remember who brought up this trick, but it is one of my top 5
tricks ever learned on this list.
Stéphane Collin
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC