While were at it, why not explain that bobbling is the butt bouncing on the jack top which hasn't cycled out of the way. So the question Matthew needs to answer is how do I get the jack to move farther out from under the butt... David Ilvedson, RPT Pacifica, CA 94044 ----- Original message ---------------------------------------- From: "Israel Stein" <custos3 at comcast.net> To: pianotech at ptg.org Received: 5/7/2009 6:01:27 PM Subject: [pianotech] Hammer Line Issue >Hello, >I have followed this with a great deal of interest, and at this point I >feel myself compelled to chime in. The hammer bobbling, or dithering or >whatever you want to call it (assuming that this is strictly a >regulation problem) can be caused by either the keydip being too >shallow, or the strike distance being too long. If the problem is the >keydip, this in turn could have been caused by the key level having >dropped (due to settling of the balance punchings) or whatever other >reason. Before deciding what to do, one should: >1. Measure the strike distance. If it's 2 inches - the problem isn't >keydip. >2. Measure the keydip. If it's 7/16 in. (11 mm.) or more - I wouldn't go >any deeper... >3. Check the key level with relation to the keyslip. Is there a "dip" in >the middle of the keyboard? Well, then you level the keys before going >any further. Of course to do this, one needs to know the parameters for >key level with relation to the balance pins, key slip, front pin, etc. >Matthew, like the man said - learn how the action works and how the >various functions interrelate. And get familiar with plausible >regulation specs. Get the manufacturer's specs and see if the piano is >anywhere close to them. >Just telling Matthew to "do this" and "do that" without any context >doesn't do much good either for his learning curve or for his client... >Often this sort of approach will solve a problem at the cost of creating >two new ones. Sort of like digging a second hole to bury the dirt from >digging the first one. >Israel Stein >> >> >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> >> Subject: >> Re: [pianotech] Hammer Line Issue >> From: >> "Tom Driscoll" <tomtuner at verizon.net> >> Date: >> Thu, 07 May 2009 19:57:19 -0400 >> To: >> <pianotech at ptg.org> >> >> To: >> <pianotech at ptg.org> >> >> >> Matthew >> Good job. As for the dithering hammers ( one of our English >> contributors used the term and I love it!) I think someone mentioned >> decreasing the tension on damper lever springs. This was for the >> Yamaha actions that have the problem that Matthew describes. >> Listees' am I remembering that correctly? >> I'm also with David on no more than 1/8th letoff combined with >> an increase in dip.With letoff more than 1/8th the hammer has to be >> thrown across too far a distance to allow soft play. The increase in >> dip - aftertouch will move the top of the jack away from the >> returning butt and help with the symptom. >> I think Ron N. mentioned that there is a geometry problem with the >> Yamaha jack that leads to bobbling hammers on a soft blow. I wonder if >> the Kawai has the same issue. Again ,good job. I'll bet they were >> pleased with what you accomplished. >> Tom D. >> >> >> Bring the letoff back to 1/8" and increase the dip so the hammer >> doesn't bounce off the jack. >> >> >> >> dp >> >> >> >> >> >> David M. Porritt, RPT >> >> >> >> I serviced the Kawai today. >> >> >> >> I adjusted the capstans, letoff and checking. It went really >> well. Although, when I was doing the letoff, I couldn't get the >> piano to do 1/8''. When I did 1/8'', and then pressed the note >> pianissimo, it would double strike, so I did just a little bit >> more letoff and the issue resolved. >> >> Here is a bigger question. After I finished, I played a Bach >> piece, and one thing I did notice was that it was somewhat >> difficult for me to play really soft. Is there something more I >> need to do to obtain this? Or, maybe to state it better, I could >> play "forte" and even "piano", but to obtain a "mezzo piano" was >> difficult. What can I do that would help with the dynamics? >> >> >> >> Thanks again for all your help, >> >> *_TODD PIANO WORKS_* >> Matthew Todd, Piano Technician >> >> >> >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> >> _______________________________________________ >> pianotech mailing list >> pianotech at ptg.org >> http://ptg.org/mailman/listinfo/pianotech_ptg.org >>
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC