<HTML><HEAD>
<META content="MSHTML 6.00.2900.2802" name=GENERATOR></HEAD>
<BODY>Don has it right. For the newer guy that asked and all others who may be in doubt: Do NOT use F3 to compare fork/A4 beat rates. Use ONLY F2 or B1<BR><BR>I am too lazy and busy at the moment to explain the science of WHY but it is in the archives and many other sources.<BR><BR>If one uses F3 and A4 happens to come out exactly right, <EM>it is a lucky accident</EM> and, in fact, they actually will have tuned the note "wrong" as to matching beat rates, otherwise it would NOT have come out "right" as to pitch!<BR><BR>This is not a theory to be debated, it is an axiom and a scientific certainty. So make it an unbreakable rule: <EM><STRONG>Do NOT USE F3 in tuning A4.<BR></STRONG></EM><BR>Puff, pant, rave, rant. (Not really, it was just fun making that little rhyme.) <G><BR><BR>Alan Barnard<BR>Salem, Missouri<BR><BR><BR>> [Original Message]<BR>> From: Don <pianotuna@yahoo.com><BR>> To: Pianotech <pianotech@ptg.org><BR>> Date: 01/08/2006 11:35:43 AM<BR>> Subject: Re: NO NO NO was Re: electronic pitch source<BR>><BR>>> Yes you may have--but only because you failed to make the beat rate between<BR>> f3 and a4 (actually a5) identical. If you had then A4 would have been flat.<BR>> It might still be within the "tolerance" range on the exam however.<BR>><BR>> Or else your carefully "calibrated" fork was sharp (cooling as you struck it?)<BR>><BR></BODY></HTML>